Wednesday 13 April 2011

DVD Review- The Girl Who Played With Fire

Some of us have read em all, some of us are doin the fillums. I just watched no. 2 of the Lisbeth and Micke saga. here's my thorts....* spoiler alert if you're keen to see it*
- Once again the Swedes knock the socks off anything the US are likely to do with this story. Noomi Rapace is a forceful Lisbeth. They play a subtle tiger/lion growl in the soundtrack under some of her most intense moments....she doesnt need it.
- For one I find meself agreeing with a point made by David Stratton. He mentioned that a difficulty with this fillum is that the two protagonists, Lisbeth and Micke, never really meet until the end. This creates a difficulty for the fillum makers in terms of creating any  dynamic between them. I agree. But I want to take the rant further, eg:
- one of the really interesting things about all three books are their observations of human relationship through the mediums of newspapers, mobile phones and computers. This simply cannot be adequately portrayed through film, because the relationships extend beyond the pictorial.
-  Some of the most fascinating things about the Girl who Plays With Fire then Kicks the Hornet Nest are the hidden interplays between all of the characters, and how they are traced. It would make boring boring film, which is why it's downplayed. But it gives me hope! So often I hear media and people in general wailing that social media is creating a society who no longer relate. Maybe this aint necessarily so. But maybe the power of the piccy is losing its grip upon us, now that we can walk around with little headpieces looking as if we're talking to ourselves, or have interesting conversations and even relationships of a kind (here's looking at you all )without having any kind of connection in the 'real world'. The written word is coming back into its own.
- Stieg Larsson was a crusader against corruption in Sweden. The three books, but especially the last two, are a fictional exposition of layers and layers of corruption. They also expose 'corruption in the making' as they explore the behaviour of the media and the police towards Lisbeth Salander. They're an observation of group dynamics as well as the way in which each individual can have an impact on an outcome. The films seem to be setting all of this aside and focusing on the goodies vs the baddies, which is of course a very valid thing for people making a film to do. But all that texture....read the books, oh, read the books...
- Hubby had issues with Lisbeth's disembodied hand digging her thrice shot body out of a grave and carting herself off to find Daddy. Having read the book, I did not. But it did threaten to cross into Night Of the Living Dead Territory, for hubby..

6 comments:

  1. thorough comments, Missus. I might have to re-glance at the book to distinguish what happened in book 2 vs book 3.

    One detail which I approved of was the omission of Lisbeth's boob job. It seemed totally out of character when reading, & I'm glad it was skipped.
    Also in the book, that whole episode with the occupants of room 32 seemed unrelated and irrelevant, other than to show a bit of Lisbeth's character. I was glad that was omitted from the movie.

    I thought the lesbo scene at the start of the movie was a little gratuitous.

    Didn't watch any of the grave digging, but could imagine it was gruesome.

    Definitely, the story was abridged. I'm sure the watching pleasure would be less significant without reading the novel first.

    ReplyDelete
  2. inneresting Betty!
    I see what you mean about the boob job. And the occupants of room 32. But I wonder...Larsson had TEN novels in this series planned. He only got to write 3 before he died. His partner ( I think) has the unfinished draft of the fourth and she's refusing (so far) to allow it to be published. Maybe some of the loose ends would have been attended to eventually?
    Harriet from book 1 was all set up to become a lot more than books 2 & 3 allowed her to become as well. Wonder what he had in store for her?
    The lesbo scene/s were poifikly in context in the book. Poor old Lisbeth. They had to give her SOME human warmth in film 2....

    ReplyDelete
  3. Will you be able to catch movie 3 while it's still showing at the cinemas?

    ReplyDelete
  4. hola swede booksters.

    thinking on what you say about the written word coming back into its own, wilms .... I agree that it doesn't obviate intimacy. many a gorjus warm fuzzy relationship was built on paper up until relatively recently - profound intimacy could be reached via a carefully crafted letter or two.

    be that as it may .... ta for the review :D. having not read books I'm a little at sea on most of it, but see your point about the lost layers and intricacies. still, it'll be worserer in the hands of the yanks!

    ReplyDelete
  5. night of the living dead ..... snorffles!

    ReplyDelete
  6. @ Daisy..may end up catching no 3 on dvd. Movie nights are few & far between. Looks like this Sunday is a date with destiny, however. Jimmy Giggle (Giggle & Hoot, ABC) is doing a meet & greet at our local hyperhellmall, outside the cinema. My sis & her kids are down from Sydney. Rio (new film from Ice Age producers) is on. I surrender.

    ReplyDelete